The great sagas of
the Indogermanic tradition, Beowulf, Siegfried, Herakles, Theseus, Grettir,
which present a hero who defeats some goblin foe either in the form of
man or dragon, have been hitherto considered largely from the literary
standpoint. The stories they tell have been regarded as a blend of myth
and legend, but in any case as mere products of imagination. This is especially
true of Beowulf, which Frederick Panzer, for instance, regards as a fairytale
showing a strong resemblance to the well known son of the bear group of
tales. The development of the sciences of anthropology and psychology in
recent years has opened a field of research which provides, however, material
which will enable us to go below these existing strata of myth and legend
to inquire into the most primitive origin of tales that in so many diverse
countries show such marked features in common. The similarity of the achievements
of the heroes is accounted for, I think, by the explanation that Beowulf
and Grettir and Herakles represent famous exorcists who practised a very
old folk custom, the expulsion of demons, just as to this day it is practised
in Indian and African villages. This custom is so widely spread over the
whole Earth that it would be remarkable if it had been entirely unknown
to the Indogermanic and the Germanic tribes. The reason why this explanation
has not been found before lies in the fact that mostly the magician or
medicine man is used to fight the supernatural dangers, the demons, because
he is believed to be nearer to the supernatural than other men. The magician
incorporates and cultivates the mastery, the expulsion of demonic moods,
melancholies, panics and obsessions. In early Indogermanic and Germanic
times there was practically no definite class of priests and magicians.
Here the hero who has distinguished himself by his courage, independence,
and physical force and thus proved his fame, is the main figure in his
tribe. Is it then to be wondered at that the Sagas from Herakles to Beowulf
portray the famous and strong hero as the victor in fights with ghosts
and trolls, with human anddragon shaped demons?
The most plastic
and realistic example of Germanic tradition of demonic obsession and its
cure, its expulsion by a hero, is the Grettir Saga. Grettir Asmundarson
is an historically authentic figure. He was born in the year 996, four
years after the introduction of Christianity, at Bjarg in the north of
Iceland. His desperate struggle as an outlaw, in which he persisted until
he was slain in 1031, forms the real nucleus of his fame. He has in common
with Beowulf the most important attribute, that of having repeatedly distinguished
himself in courage and in manly strength, that strongest human reality
which the Teuton was ready to trust in face of the demons. With confidence
in his own strength, and doubtless because his fellow tribesmen attributed
this ability to him, Grettir enters the haunted farms. On Thorhalstadir
a mysterious dead shepherd Glam torments the imagination of the inhabitants.
But the daring Grettir awaits him at night. The idea of the ghost develops
autosuggestion from expectation to hallucination. All at once Glam stands
before him in the semidarkness and stares at him with his terrifying eyes.
But the hero refuses to yield. He lapses info an ecstasy of defiant opposition.
He raves and strikes about himself in such a manner that the frozen earth
and grassy plots with which the roof of the log hut was covered fall down,
until at last he collapses and looses consciousness. But he must still
have had so much strength on the morning after the fight that he felt conscious
of a victory over the demon, which he then proclaimed to the terrified
peasants. So the mental epidemic which had led to the desertion of the
whole valley was stopped.
In the great Anglosaxon
epic Beowulf the hero waits for the demon Grendel according to the same
custom which one might call the demon's watch. The second expulsion here
takes place at the abode of the demon itself in a cave under the water.
The theory that the third demon, a dragon, is a ghost is illustrated by
the fact that he lies in a tomb on the treasure of an extinct family. (For
further details see Gustav Hübener, England und die Gesittunsgrundlage
der europäischen Frühgeschichte, Frankfurt am Main, 1930.) In
my opinion similar traditions may be found in every region where Germanic
custom prevails, and elsewhere within the radius of Indogermanic influence.
Moreover comparative ethnology will be able, I think, to prove that every
predominantly heroic and aristocratic tribal culture trusts the hero and
not the magician nor the priest in exorcism in conquering the demon.